Expert Evidence Standards

Juries and judges should have access to the most complete and accurate evidence during trials, and be presented with scientifically and factually accurate information to allow them to make well-informed decisions.

The Problem

Many courts have lax standards for evidence and judges who abandon their role as gatekeepers, resulting in an abundance of “junk science” evidence presented to jurors. This is especially common in litigation regarding the glyphosate-based Roundup weed killer and talcum baby powder.

ATRA’s Position

ATRA supports implementation of Federal Rule of Evidence 702 in courts, requiring that theories must be based on sound scientific method. The Rule 702 standard is utilized in the federal court system and by a majority of states. Further, ATRA believes judges must follow applicable laws regarding evidentiary standards if they are in place in their state.

Search Through ATRA Reforms

Search through all of ATRA's reforms around Expert Evidence Standards

No related legislation or reform items to display.



Expert Evidence Standards News and Press

Explore ATRA's most recent press releases and blogs around Expert Evidence Standards

Lawsuit Abuse Awareness Week 2026: Somebody Paid for That Billboard. It Was You.

You see the ads on the interstate, between innings and during the 11 oR...

Kansas a “Tort Reform Trailblazer” After Lawmakers Override Vetoes, Pass Sweeping Legal Reforms

Kansas lawmakers earned a “Tort Reform Trailblazer” designation in the Ame...

Wisconsin Named “Tort Reform Trailblazer” After Lawmakers Crack Down on Junk Science in Courts

Wisconsin earned national recognition as a “Tort Reform Trailblazer” in th...

Search Resources

Search through all of ATRA's Amicus Briefs, Reports, and Other Resources around Expert Evidence Standards
Search All
States
Status
Post Types
Date
Comment by Leading Defense Bar and Business Groups Opposing Nonlawyer Ownership and Fee-Sharing
Tennessee Supreme Court comment by leading business and defense bar groups opposing nonlawyer law firm ownership – 4.30.2026Download ...
Tennessee
Blade v. Sig Sauer
(E.D. Pa., filed April 6, 2026): Arguing that the court should grant Sig Saurer’s motion for reconsideration because Mallory upends the jurisdictiona...
Eastern District of Pennsylvania
  • Case Not Yet Decided iconCase Not Yet Decided
In Re Northern California Clergy Cases
(Cal. App., filed March 30, 2026): Arguing that neither the text of Proposition 51 nor the text of AB 218 supports the plaintiffs’ argument that join...
California
  • Case Not Yet Decided iconCase Not Yet Decided
Suquilanda v. Skyway Roofing, Inc.
(Ma., filed March 18, 2026): Urging the court to decline to recognize a new cause of action permitting employees of a subcontractor to sue a contract...
Massachusetts
  • Case Not Yet Decided iconCase Not Yet Decided
Letter Urging Veto or Amendments to House Bill 449 / Senate Bill 229 in Virginia
...
Virginia
Corporate Flight from Delaware: The Impact of Escalating Shareholder Litigation and Legal Uncertainty
Unpredictable court rulings and a wave of lawyer-driven, profit-seeking litigation are destabilizing Delaware’s historic dominance for corporat...
Delaware
New York Local Legal Services Advertising 2024-2025
Trial lawyers and aggregators increasingly spend large sums of money on television, digital, and print advertising to recruit new clients. In 2025, i...
New York
Murphy v. Rio Rancho Center
(New Mex. Ct. App., filed March 5, 2026): Arguing that the double-digit punitive multipliers likely violate due process. The U.S. Supreme Court has s...
New Mexico
  • Case Not Yet Decided iconCase Not Yet Decided
Sommerville v. Union Carbide Corp.
(U.S., filed March 6, 2026): Arguing that Rule 702’s gatekeeping function is grounded in the need to protect juries from unreliable evidence.  The de...
SCOTUS
  • Case Not Yet Decided iconCase Not Yet Decided
Monsanto v. Durnell
(U.S., filed March 2, 2026): Arguing that requirements for herbicide labeling should not be made case-by-case in litigation sparked by a flawed IARC ...
SCOTUS
  • Court Ruled in Favor of ATRA's Position iconCourt Ruled in Favor of ATRA's Position



The American Tort Reform Association is the nation’s first organization dedicated exclusively to reforming the civil justice system through education and legislative enactment.

To receive occasional updates from ATRA, enter your email address:
By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy and consent to receive updates.
© 2026 ATRA. All rights reserved.